Bermuda Post

Thursday, Mar 28, 2024

Growing evidence suggests transgender females maintain natural athletic advantages over girls

Growing evidence suggests transgender females maintain natural athletic advantages over girls

Research indicates puberty confers lasting physical primacy for boys, even after months or years of estrogen.

A small but growing body of research suggests that trans female athletes (born male, identifying as female) retain a significant natural advantage over their female competitors even after extended periods of synthetic hormone treatment. The findings could potentially throw a wrench in efforts by LGBTQ activists and the Biden administration to increase transgender representation in female sport leagues.

Debate has swirled for years around whether boys who assert a female identity should be permitted to compete against girls in secondary and collegiate sports divisions. Activists have argued that trans women should be treated as identical to biological women in essentially every way, including, controversially, in athletic competition.

Counterarguments, meanwhile, have held that males continue to retain marked physical advantages over female athletes, even if the former identify as girls.

The pro-transgender effort received a major boost last month from newly-sworn-in President Joe Biden, who signed an executive order on his first day in office aimed at "preventing and combating discrimination on the basis of gender identity or sexual orientation."

In that order, which cited Supreme Court precedent and federal civil rights law, Biden argued: "Children should be able to learn without worrying about whether they will be denied access to the restroom, the locker room, or school sports." The order was widely seen as an affirmation that the Biden administration would be pursuing a policy of transgender acceptance in educational environments, including sporting leagues.

Studies point to continued advantages even after hormone therapy


That males overwhelmingly tend on balance to enjoy superior athletic ability relative to females remains largely uncontested. The sport debate largely hinges on whether biological males who identify as females maintain distinct physical advantages over girls and women — particularly after extended periods on synthetic estrogen supplements — and whether permitting them to compete in women's sports puts female athletes at an unfair disadvantage.

Emerging evidence suggests that, even after significant amounts of time spent on estrogen, male athletes retain notable edges in athletic performance, potentially foreshadowing a difficult set of social and political choices in deciding whether or not transgender inclusion outweighs what may effectively function as athletic disenfranchisement for young female athletes.

One study, published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine in December, sought to "examine the effect of gender affirming hormones on athletic performance among transwomen and transmen."

Drawing on "fitness test results and medical records of 29 transmen and 46 transwomen who started gender affirming hormones while in the United States Air Force," the researchers found that "prior to gender affirming hormones, transwomen [males who identify as women] performed 31% more push-ups and 15% more sit-ups in 1 min and ran 1.5 miles 21% faster than their female counterparts."

"After 2 years of taking feminising hormones," the researchers write, "the push-up and sit-up differences disappeared but transwomen were still 12% faster."

In another study published the same month in the journal Sports Medicine, the authors sought to determine "whether evidence exists to support the assumption that testosterone suppression in transgender women removes the male performance advantage and thus delivers fair and safe competition."

The scientists found that "current evidence shows the biological advantage, most notably in terms of muscle mass and strength, conferred by male puberty and thus enjoyed by most transgender women is only minimally reduced when testosterone is suppressed as per current sporting guidelines for transgender athletes."

Noting that estrogen supplements appear to have no effect on "skeletal size and bone density," the writers point out that any advantages conferred by those attributes are unlikely to be affected by hormone treatment.

Citing research into muscle size and body mass retention during testosterone suppression, the writers also argue that "the muscle mass advantage males possess over females, and the performance implications thereof," appear to remain unaffected over the course of at least several years.

"In sports where muscle mass is important for performance," they write, "inclusion is therefore only possible if a large imbalance in fairness, and potentially safety in some sports, is to be tolerated."

'The voices of female athletes need to be heard'


Transgenderism itself has become a deeply fraught issue in modern American society. Activists have demanded the upending of deeply embedded cultural norms to accommodate trans individuals — including allowing biologically male trans females to use the bathroom and showering facilities of girls. A small but vocal network of commentators and advocates, meanwhile, has attempted to push back against that rapidly solidifying regime.

Arlette Perry, a clinical exercise psychologist at the University of Miami, argues that the data are still too sparse to make a determination one way or the other.

"I believe there is just not sufficient scientific data to say one way or the other with regard to transgender athletic competition," she said. "There are just too few transgender athletes at this time to draw any significant conclusions."

Jeremy Fransen, an assistant professor of exercise science at Aurora University, acknowledged that "there could be some physical advantages that trans women could retain that would give them an advantage in some sports some of the time."

"For example, having a larger skeletal structure and mass could be advantageous for strength sports (e.g., powerlifting)," he told Just the news, "but wouldn't be helpful for certain endurance sports (e.g., marathon)."

"Success in athletic competition is a highly complex mix of physiological and psychological components," Fransen said. "For example, you could lower the amount of testosterone (sex hormone) in trans women to that of cis women, but there are other things to consider, like the amount of free vs bound testosterone and sensitivity of muscle receptors to testosterone."

Where female-identifying male athletes have been permitted to compete in girl's leagues, the results have at times been decisive. In Connecticut several years ago, two transgender athletes allowed to compete against girls quickly broke numerous state records in the female divisions, leading to claims from numerous female athletes that they enjoyed an unfair competitive advantage due to their male bodies.

The Department of Education last year concluded that Connecticut discriminated against girls by allowing trans females to compete against them. Fransen argued that policymakers should consider female athletes' opinions when crafting transgender sports rules.

"I think the best thing from a policy standpoint is to ask female athletes, as they are the population most affected," he said. "The voice of female athletes from high school through college and professional needs to be heard."

"One solution may be to create a new transgender division in most sports," he said. "In some sports (race car driving) it may not matter at all and there is no need. Again, it's a larger discussion among the particular athletes in each sport."

'The biggest objections that I've seen are from the females'


The issue has become a flashpoint in the larger ongoing cultural battle surrounding transgenderism, a topic which includes such questions as whether or not doctors should remove healthy body parts to conform a patient's body to his or her "gender identity" and whether young children should be given synthetic hormones in accordance with their professed gender.

Transgender athletics arose in the U.S. Senate this week when Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul grilled Miguel Cardona, Joe Biden's nominee for Secretary of Education, over his position on males competing against females in school athletics.

Mostly dodging Paul's aggressive questions on the matter, Cardona ultimately said: "I think it's the legal responsibility for schools to provide opportunities for students to participate in activities, and this includes students who are transgender."

In other strata of society, the issue is at times difficult to broach. Warren Whisenant, the chair of the kinesiology and sports sciences department at the University of Miami, said that, along with racial issues, gender is one of the topics about which "students become very reluctant to speak out in class."

"To guide them through an open dialogue can be somewhat difficult at times," he said.. "The students, they don't want to be accused of being homophobic or racist."

Whisenant, who teaches a Contemporary Issues in Sport in North America class, said he has observed a "shift" in the last several years regarding transgender ideology among his students.

"Five years ago, students were absolutely against it," he said. "Now there seems to be a bit more support."

"[T]he biggest objections that I've seen from students are from the females," he added. "Girls do feel that in many instances, from a physiological standpoint, that males who haven't gone through a 'transition' process possess a competitive advantage. Those students tend to shy away from [debate].

"The males in the classes, for whatever reason, don't feel as threatened by the idea of a female who transitioned to a male," he said. "They tend to be much more accepting of the females who transition."

Newsletter

Related Articles

Bermuda Post
0:00
0:00
Close
Paper straws found to contain long-lasting and potentially toxic chemicals - study
FTX's Bankman-Fried headed for jail after judge revokes bail
Blackrock gets half a trillion dollar deal to rebuild Ukraine
Steve Jobs' Son Launches Venture Capital Firm With $200 Million For Cancer Treatments
Israel: Unprecedented Civil Disobedience Looms as IDF Reservists Protest Judiciary Reform
Google reshuffles Assistant unit, lays off some staffers, to 'supercharge' products with A.I.
End of Viagra? FDA approved a gel against erectile dysfunction
UK sanctions Russians judges over dual British national Kara-Murza's trial
US restricts visa-free travel for Hungarian passport holders because of security concerns
America's First New Nuclear Reactor in Nearly Seven Years Begins Operations
Southeast Asia moves closer to economic unity with new regional payments system
Political leader from South Africa, Julius Malema, led violent racist chants at a massive rally on Saturday
Today Hunter Biden’s best friend and business associate, Devon Archer, testified that Joe Biden met in Georgetown with Russian Moscow Mayor's Wife Yelena Baturina who later paid Hunter Biden $3.5 million in so called “consulting fees”
Singapore Carries Out First Execution of a Woman in Two Decades Amid Capital Punishment Debate
Spanish Citizenship Granted to Iranian chess player who removed hijab
US Senate Republican Mitch McConnell freezes up, leaves press conference
Speaker McCarthy says the United States House of Representatives is getting ready to impeach Joe Biden.
San Francisco car crash
This camera man is a genius
3D ad in front of Burj Khalifa
Next level gaming
Google testing journalism AI. We are doing it already 2 years, and without Google biased propoganda and manipulated censorship
Unlike illegal imigrants coming by boats - US Citizens Will Need Visa To Travel To Europe in 2024
Musk announces Twitter name and logo change to X.com
'I just lost it' Lowe’s worker fired after 13 years of employment for confronting thieves trying to steal $2K of merchandise
The politician and the journalist lost control and started fighting on live broadcast.
The future of sports
Unveiling the Black Hole: The Mysterious Fate of EU's Aid to Ukraine
Farewell to a Music Titan: Tony Bennett, Renowned Jazz and Pop Vocalist, Passes Away at 96
Alarming Behavior Among Florida's Sharks Raises Concerns Over Possible Cocaine Exposure
Transgender Exclusion in Miss Italy Stirs Controversy Amidst Changing Global Beauty Pageant Landscape
Joe Biden admitted, in his own words, that he delivered what he promised in exchange for the $10 million bribe he received from the Ukraine Oil Company.
TikTok Takes On Spotify And Apple, Launches Own Music Service
Global Trend: Using Anti-Fake News Laws as Censorship Tools - A Deep Dive into Tunisia's Scenario
Arresting Putin During South African Visit Would Equate to War Declaration, Asserts President Ramaphosa
Hacktivist Collective Anonymous Launches 'Project Disclosure' to Unearth Information on UFOs and ETIs
Typo sends millions of US military emails to Russian ally Mali
Server Arrested For Theft After Refusing To Pay A Table's $100 Restaurant Bill When They Dined & Dashed
The Changing Face of Europe: How Mass Migration is Reshaping the Political Landscape
China Urges EU to Clarify Strategic Partnership Amid Trade Tensions
Europe is boiling: Extreme Weather Conditions Prevail Across the Continent
The Last Pour: Anchor Brewing, America's Pioneer Craft Brewer, Closes After 127 Years
Democracy not: EU's Digital Commissioner Considers Shutting Down Social Media Platforms Amid Social Unrest
Sarah Silverman and Renowned Authors Lodge Copyright Infringement Case Against OpenAI and Meta
Italian Court's Controversial Ruling on Sexual Harassment Ignites Uproar
Why Do Tech Executives Support Kennedy Jr.?
The New York Times Announces Closure of its Sports Section in Favor of The Athletic
BBC Anchor Huw Edwards Hospitalized Amid Child Sex Abuse Allegations, Family Confirms
Florida Attorney General requests Meta CEO's testimony on company's platforms' alleged facilitation of illicit activities
The Distorted Mirror of actual approval ratings: Examining the True Threat to Democracy Beyond the Persona of Putin
×